Message/Author 

Xu, Man posted on Thursday, June 18, 2009  9:22 am



Dear Dr Muthen, To test a cross level interaction, I include in the model a cross product term(X*Z) as the interaction term between a level 1 varaible(X) and a level 2 variable(Z). In this model the slope is fixed: Yij=B0j+B1*Xij+B2*X*Zj B0j=B0++B01*Zj+U0j+e0ij This way B2 is the interaction effect. Another way might be to make the slop of X random such that a cross level interaction is present Yij=B0j+B1j*Xij B0j=B00+B01*Zj+U0j+e0ij B1j=B10+B11*Zj+U1j Here B11 would be the interaction effect. I found that the interaction effects in both methods are very similar, although there are slight difference in standard errors. Could you advice me which way is better and why? And does the substantive interpretations of the interactions remain the same? Thank you! Xu, Man 


I would use the second way with BETWEEN=z; The first way doesn't have U1j. 

Xu, Man posted on Sunday, June 21, 2009  6:10 am



Yes. Thank you. In my model I didn't really specify any variable to be within or between. I think the random slope approach is better for interaction of within and between variables because my z is a latently aggarated variable from a within level variable. If I used the product term I created from manifest group averages then the interaction effect probably won't be in agreement with the latent aggaration framework. I also tried to "trick" a latent interaction by specifying a "xwith" term of one indicator variables at within and between level, but this idea didn't work at all. 

T Davis posted on Wednesday, November 03, 2010  7:55 am



Drs. Muthen  This is a very helpful post. I have a few questions. What would the model command look like? I am not sure how the X*Z interaction is modeled. In the User's Guide ex. 9.1 it appears that the X*Z interaction is represented as xm. Is this correct? So for a random intercept model with two crosslevel interactions, the MODEL command would look like: %WITHIN% y on x1 x2 %BETWEEN% y on w x1m x2m Can this be modeled in version 5.1? Thank you. 


A crosslevel interaction is modeled when you have a random slope as shown in Example 9.2. See Slide 45 of the Topic 7 course handout on the website to see how this plays out. I think this was available in Version 5.1. 

Back to top 